Itchy Ice Cream is a recipe seen in the Cookbook as Kelly was flipping through it. It has never been cooked before on the show, it has only been seen in the book. Its first book appearance was in Just Add Mom. In Just Add Betrayal, it is revealed that Nöelle Jasper, RJ White, and Arthur invented this recipe and used it on one of their teachers in a flashback. The recipe is also mentioned in Season 1, when they're looking through the cookbook to find a spell to use. Darbie suggests giving it to their math teacher, but they tell her not to.
- Pinch of Werpoes salt
- 1 cup milk
- 1/2 cup cream
- Plenty of ice
- 1/2 cup sugar
- Pour sugar, cream and milk into a sauce pan over low just until sugar has dissolved.
- Transfer mixture to a pour-able container
- Put the mixture in the freezer for at least 7 hours ( overnight is best ) riddle, downside " if you want to make someone itch then let him take a bite and watch it happen at night."